Effectiveness of Virtual Reality in Participatory Urban Planning: A Case Study

PubDate: November 2018

Teams: The Hague University of Applied Sciences，Municipality of The Hague，Twynstra & Gudde Utrecht

Writers: Jos P. van Leeuwen；Klaske Hermans；Antti Jylhä；Arnold Jan Quanjer；Hanke Nijman

PDF: Effectiveness of Virtual Reality in Participatory Urban Planning: A Case Study

Abstract

In urban planning, 3D modeling and virtual reality (VR) provide new means for involving citizens in the planning process. For municipal government, it is essential to know how effective these means are, to justify investments. In this study, we present a case of using VR in a municipal process of civic participation concerning the redesign of a public park. The process included co-design activities and involved citizens in decision-making through a ballot, using 3D-rendered versions of competing designs. In co-design, 3D-modeling tools were instrumental in empowering citizens to negotiate design decisions, to discuss the quality of designs with experts, and to collectively take decisions. This paper demonstrates that, in a ballot on competing designs with 1302 citizens, VR headsets proved to be equally effective compared to other display technologies in informing citizens during decision making. The results of an additional, controlled experiment indicate that VR headsets provide higher engagement and more vivid memories than viewing the designs on non-immersive displays.

By integrating research into a municipal process, we contribute evidence of cognitive and engagement effects of using 3D modeling and immersive VR technologies to empower citizens in participatory urban planning. The case described in the paper concerns a public park; a similar approach could be applied to the design of public installations including media architecture.